The Question to Settle Before Comparing Feature Lists
If you're weighing Huntress vs Sophos MDR, with Blackpoint Cyber also on the shortlist, you're probably in one of two seats. You're an IT lead at a 20- to 500-person company with no security operations center, or you're an MSP choosing one MDR stack to roll out across dozens of clients. All three vendors sell to both groups, but each is built mainly for one, and that matters more than any datasheet.
The question that sorts them: who is allowed to act on your environment at 3 a.m., and how far can they go? Isolating a laptop, disabling a compromised Microsoft 365 account, killing a malicious inbox rule. Those actions stop a ransomware or business email compromise incident. A service that only alerts you isn't giving you detection and response. It's giving you detection plus a pager.
This comparison covers five things buyers keep asking about: response authority, Microsoft 365 and identity coverage, pricing model, regional SOC presence and data residency, and how cyber insurers treat each service. Verdicts by buyer type close the piece.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
How Each Service Is Built and Sold
Huntress started in the MSP channel and still sells mostly through it, though it also sells directly to smaller businesses. The core products are Managed EDR (its own lightweight agent, which works alongside Microsoft Defender Antivirus), Managed ITDR for Microsoft 365 and Entra ID identities, a managed SIEM, and security awareness training. There's little to tune, and the SOC does the triage.
Sophos MDR comes from a large, UK-headquartered security vendor with its own endpoint, firewall, email and network products. It's sold in tiers, mainly MDR Essentials and MDR Complete, through resellers and MSPs. It can also ingest telemetry from third-party tools such as Microsoft Defender, CrowdStrike or SentinelOne. Sophos's acquisition of Secureworks added SOC capacity and incident response depth. Expect product names and integration lists to shift as the two are merged.
Blackpoint Cyber sells only through MSPs. Its platform, marketed as CompassOne, combines its own endpoint agent with cloud response for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace. The selling point is speed: its SOC contains threats by default rather than waiting for approval.
| Factor | Huntress | Sophos MDR | Blackpoint Cyber MDR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary channel | MSPs, plus direct to SMBs | Resellers, MSPs, direct | MSPs only |
| Endpoint agent | Own agent alongside Defender AV | Sophos endpoint, or third-party EDR | Own agent, can run alongside existing AV/EDR |
| Identity / M365 | Managed ITDR add-on | Included integrations, varies by tier | Cloud response add-on |
| Best-known strength | Simplicity, SMB fit | Breadth, tiered IR, global footprint | Fast default containment |
Response Authority: What They'll Do Without Calling You
Ask every vendor which actions the SOC takes on its own and which need your approval.
Blackpoint is the most aggressive by design. Its analysts isolate hosts and contain identities once they confirm a threat, then notify the MSP. MSPs burned by slow callbacks tend to like this. The trade-off: a production server can get isolated during business hours, so agree on exclusions for critical systems up front.
Huntress isolates endpoints and, with ITDR, disables users and revokes sessions when indicators are clear. Some remediation comes back to you or your MSP as guided tasks, many with one-click approval, rather than being done end to end. For a lean team, that means short tasks you can't skip.
Sophos makes response authority a setting: notify only, collaborate, or authorize Sophos to act fully. MDR Complete adds full-scale incident response without a separate retainer. The flexibility is useful, but plenty of buyers pick "collaborate" during onboarding and never revisit it, which brings the 3 a.m. pager problem back.
Our position: with one or two IT staff and no overnight cover, grant full authority to act, whichever vendor you pick. Then write down the five or ten systems that need a phone call first.
Microsoft 365 and Identity Coverage
Most small-company breaches now run through identity rather than malware: a stolen session token, a fraudulent inbox-forwarding rule, a rogue OAuth app consent. An MDR service that only watches endpoints misses these entirely, so this criterion carries heavy weight for any small-business deployment.
- Huntress Managed ITDR is the most focused Microsoft 365 product of the three. It watches for suspicious-location sign-ins, malicious inbox rules and risky app consents, and it can disable accounts and revoke sessions. It doesn't cover Google Workspace the same way, so check its current scope if you run Google.
- Sophos MDR ingests Microsoft 365, Entra ID and other identity signals through integration packs. Which ones come bundled and which cost extra depends on tier and changes over time, so get the list in writing.
- Blackpoint offers cloud response for both Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, which helps MSPs whose clients are split between the two.
Check licensing on your side too. Some identity detections depend on Entra ID sign-in logs available only in higher license tiers, so confirm what your Microsoft 365 plan actually exposes.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Pricing Models and What Actually Drives the Bill
None of these vendors publishes one list price, and MSP pricing differs from direct pricing. The ranges below are indicative 2026 market figures for the end customer. They vary by contract, volume, term and region, so confirm them with the vendor or your MSP.
| Component | Huntress | Sophos MDR | Blackpoint (via MSP) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Billing unit | Per endpoint + per identity | Per user or device, annual term | Per endpoint, plus cloud users |
| Endpoint MDR (end-customer) | $4–10 per endpoint/month | $40–110 per user/year depending on tier | $6–14 per endpoint/month |
| Identity / M365 add-on | $3–6 per user/month | Often bundled; some integrations extra | $2–5 per user/month |
| Incident response | Remediation included; major IR often separate | Included in Complete tier | Containment included; full IR scoped separately |
Hypothetical worked example: say a 60-person firm has 70 endpoints and 60 Microsoft 365 users. Huntress EDR plus ITDR at mid-range rates comes to roughly $7,000–11,000 a year. A Sophos MDR Complete quote covering users and devices might land around $5,000–8,000, and it replaces the endpoint protection license too. Blackpoint through an MSP might run $7,000–12,000, often folded into the MSP's per-seat fee.
What moves the bill most: server counts (often priced higher), minimum seat commitments, multi-year terms, and whether you're replacing an existing antivirus license or stacking on top of it.
Regional SOC Presence, Data Residency and Language
Outside North America, this criterion often decides the deal.
Sophos has the widest international footprint. It runs SOCs on several continents and hosts its Sophos Central platform in multiple regions, including Europe and Asia-Pacific. That helps buyers who need EU-hosted telemetry for GDPR comfort, or who face data-localization expectations in India, the Gulf states or parts of Latin America. Ask which country your data is stored in and where the analysts working your alerts sit.
Huntress has grown its customer and partner base internationally, notably in the UK, Europe and Australia/New Zealand. Ask directly about current hosting regions and whether analysts in your time zone handle your alerts. Don't assume they do.
Blackpoint has historically been centered on North America, though it has expanded through MSP partners in other English-speaking markets. A European, Middle Eastern or Southeast Asian MSP should check data location, language support and whether its clients' sector regulators allow processing outside the country.
If you fall under the EU's NIS2 Directive, Singapore's Cybersecurity Act, India's CERT-In incident reporting rules or a similar regime, your MDR provider must supply evidence fast enough to meet short reporting deadlines, in some regimes measured in hours. Ask each vendor how quickly they produce an incident timeline.
Insurer Acceptance and the Underwriting Questionnaire
Cyber insurers in most markets now ask whether you run EDR on all endpoints and whether it's monitored 24/7. Underwriters generally treat all three services as meeting that bar when fully deployed. Insurers don't formally endorse vendors, though, and requirements vary by carrier and country.
What trips buyers up isn't the brand. It's coverage gaps. Tell an insurer that EDR covers "all endpoints," then suffer a breach that starts on an unmonitored server, and you could have a disclosure problem at claim time. Before renewal:
- Export an agent-coverage report and reconcile it against your asset inventory.
- Confirm identity monitoring covers every Microsoft 365 or Google tenant you listed.
- Check whether your policy requires the insurer's panel incident response firm. Sophos MDR Complete includes IR, but your carrier may still insist on its own panel vendor for a covered claim.
Sophos has offered a breach protection warranty with some MDR Complete subscriptions in certain regions. It isn't insurance and doesn't replace a policy. Ask a licensed broker how any vendor warranty interacts with your cover.
Red Flags to Test During a Trial
All three vendors generally offer trials or proof-of-concept deployments. Use them to test these points:
- Time to contain, not time to alert. Run a benign attack simulation and measure the minutes until the host is isolated.
- Escalation contacts after hours. Who gets called, in what order, and what happens if nobody answers?
- False-positive handling. How quickly do they tune out noise from your line-of-business software?
- Offboarding. Can you export detections and incident history if you leave? MSPs should confirm this for each client tenant.
- Integration claims. If they say they "support" your firewall or backup tool, ask whether that means real detections or just log storage.
A vendor that can't give a clear written answer on points one and two during the sales process won't get clearer after you sign.
Verdict: Which MDR Fits Which Buyer
Lean IT team at a 20–150-person company on Microsoft 365, buying direct: Huntress. Endpoint plus ITDR covers two of the most common ways small companies get breached, and it asks the least of a stretched team. Grant it full containment authority.
Mid-size company (150–1,000 people), multi-site or with data-residency requirements: Sophos MDR Complete. You get regional hosting, broad integrations, bundled incident response and one vendor for endpoint protection. Set response mode to full authorization on day one.
MSP that wants to stop overnight escalations: Blackpoint, if its regional presence fits your market, because default containment takes the night shift off your plate. Huntress is the stronger pick for MSPs that want low per-seat cost, easy rollout and a mature partner program. Sophos suits MSPs that already resell Sophos firewalls and endpoint.
Already standardized on CrowdStrike or Microsoft Defender for Endpoint: Sophos MDR, because it can operate on top of third-party EDR. That matters when ripping out existing tooling isn't an option.
Next step: send all three (or your MSP's two preferred options) the same one-page questionnaire covering response authority, identity scope, data location, IR inclusions and agent-coverage reporting. Run a two-week trial with the top two, and choose the one that contained the test threat fastest without needing you awake.